Managed Futures Investment Guide 2025: Costs, Benefits, and What You Need to Know

Investors often seek alternative assets to diversify their portfolios or hedge against volatility in U.S. equity markets. Managed futures, a specialized investment approach with over 50 years of history, have become a popular option. This guide introduces you to managed futures, highlighting their potential benefits, key research findings, and critical factors when selecting professional managers known as commodity trading advisors (CTAs).

Key Insights

• Managed futures involve portfolios of futures contracts overseen by registered CTAs.
• Thoroughly vet CTAs’ credentials, strategies, and fee structures before investing.
• They offer diversification benefits and can reduce portfolio risk, especially during market downturns.

What Are Managed Futures?

Managed futures are investment programs managed by CTAs, professionals registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission who undergo rigorous background checks and comply with strict disclosure requirements. The National Futures Association (NFA) also regulates the industry to maintain standards.

CTAs use algorithmic, discretionary, or hybrid trading methods to take long or short positions in futures contracts spanning metals, grains, equity indexes, soft commodities, currencies, and government bonds. Account minimums vary widely, from $10,000 to several million dollars.

Investors often turn to managed futures to diversify portfolios, as these investments tend to perform differently from stocks and bonds, potentially reducing overall risk and providing a hedge when traditional assets falter.

Managed Futures vs. Hedge Funds

While both operate with less regulation and employ leverage and complex strategies, CTAs primarily focus on trend-following in futures markets, whereas hedge funds use broader strategies across various asset classes. Hedge funds carry risks like illiquidity and credit exposure due to borrowing, whereas CTAs trade highly liquid, credit-protected futures, offering greater transparency and flexibility.

CTA investors benefit from real-time account access and transparent trading, unlike many hedge fund structures. Ensuring your CTA does not receive conflicting commissions is crucial to avoid conflicts of interest.

Research Findings on Managed Futures

Studies since the 1980s show that managed futures can provide downside protection during bearish markets, sometimes outperforming hedge funds in crisis periods. However, returns often resemble those of low-risk Treasury securities, questioning the size of any risk premium.

Academic debates about market efficiency and risk premiums heavily influence research on managed futures. CTAs’ trend-following strategies align with technical analysis, making their performance a subject of ongoing finance discussions.

Most managed futures success is attributed to effectively exploiting market trends, suggesting that some strategies could be replicated without high fees. Yet, for many investors, paying CTA fees is justified by the expertise required to implement these strategies effectively.

Advantages and Disadvantages

Pros

• Crisis Alpha: Managed futures often perform well during market downturns, providing downside protection.
• Diversification: They offer valuable portfolio diversification, especially when traditional assets decline.
• Flexibility: Their ability to profit from both rising and falling markets enhances adaptability.

Cons

• Reliance on Market Trends: Effectiveness diminishes in sideways or unclear markets.
• Manager Dependency: Performance heavily depends on the CTA’s skill and strategy execution.
• Fees: Management and performance fees can significantly reduce net returns.

Investing Considerations

• Understand the CTA’s trading approach and ensure it fits your risk tolerance and investment goals.
• Set realistic expectations; many CTAs succeed through diversified trend-following rather than unique managerial skill.

How to Evaluate CTAs

Before investing, review the CTA’s disclosure documents detailing their strategies, fees, and historical performance. Key evaluation points include:

Trading Strategy

Identify whether the CTA employs trend-following or market-neutral strategies and the markets involved. Confirm that their philosophy aligns with your investment objectives.

Performance History

• Drawdowns: Assess maximum losses and recovery times to understand risk exposure.
• Returns: Examine net annualized returns and compare alpha metrics against benchmarks like the S&P 500.

Risk Management

Evaluate how the CTA manages risk, including use of leverage, loss mitigation, and capital preservation strategies. Risk-adjusted metrics like Sharpe and Calmar ratios provide insight into return quality relative to risk.

Fees

Typical CTA fees include 1%-3% management fees and 15%-30% performance fees, with incentive fees charged only on new profits above prior equity highs. Confirm there are no hidden or excessive transaction fees.

Alternatives to Managed Futures

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that replicate managed futures strategies offer a more accessible option for many investors. Additionally, diversifying into assets with low correlation to stocks and bonds, such as real estate or commodities, can achieve similar goals.

Responsiveness to Market Changes

Managed futures funds are designed to rapidly adjust to market shifts using advanced algorithms and dynamic risk management, enabling them to capitalize on emerging trends and mitigate losses during volatility.

Tax Considerations

Investments in managed futures are subject to the U.S. 60/40 tax rule, where 60% of gains are taxed at long-term capital gains rates regardless of holding period, and 40% at short-term rates. Tax implications vary by jurisdiction and individual circumstances; consult a tax advisor for personalized guidance.

Conclusion

Informed due diligence is essential before investing in managed futures. When aligned with your investment goals and risk tolerance, managed futures can serve as a valuable diversification tool, potentially enhancing risk-adjusted returns. Understanding their strategies, fees, and performance characteristics will help you make better investment decisions in 2024 and beyond.

Explore useful articles in Portfolio Construction as of 15-01-2024. The article titled " Managed Futures Investment Guide 2025: Costs, Benefits, and What You Need to Know " offers in-depth analysis and practical advice in the Portfolio Construction field. Each article is carefully crafted by experts to provide maximum value to readers.

The " Managed Futures Investment Guide 2025: Costs, Benefits, and What You Need to Know " article expands your knowledge in Portfolio Construction, keeps you informed about the latest developments, and helps you make well-informed decisions. Each article is based on unique content, ensuring originality and quality.