Understanding Tradition 3 in A.A.: Membership and Belonging

An In-Depth Exploration of Tradition 3 in the 12 Traditions of A.A. and Al-Anon

Tradition 3 of Alcoholics Anonymous clearly states that the sole requirement for membership is a genuine desire to stop drinking. Similarly, Al-Anon specifies that membership is open to those affected by a relative or friend's alcoholism.

While 12-step groups have defined eligibility, the decision to belong ultimately rests with each individual member.

Unpacking Tradition 3

Alcoholics Anonymous and Al-Anon warmly welcome anyone who meets the criteria outlined in Tradition 3, leaving it to individuals to determine their sense of belonging. Attendees either find connection within the group or choose to seek support elsewhere.

The founders emphasized Tradition 3 to safeguard the fellowship from external influences, ensuring meetings remain focused on their core purpose without dilution from unrelated issues.

Some long-standing members express concern that including individuals with challenges beyond alcohol, such as drug addiction, may shift the program away from its spiritual roots and primary mission, potentially weakening its effectiveness.

Below are perspectives shared by participants from an online forum discussing this topic.

Empowering Personal Choice

"This tradition truly means that the only requirement is the desire to stop drinking. Some may not recognize or accept they have an alcohol use disorder but still want to live alcohol-free. I respect that. For those with an alcohol use disorder who prefer exclusivity, closed meetings provide that space.

Everyone seeking to quit drinking should have the freedom to choose Alcoholics Anonymous as their support system. Membership isn't mandatory; participation is voluntary. Closed meetings help protect anonymity and the spiritual foundation.

The founders learned through experience, and as a traditionalist, I want A.A. to be available whenever someone seeks help, just as it was for me. I am committed to upholding these traditions."

—Magic

Alcohol as a Drug: Shared Principles

"The principles apply equally whether the substance is alcohol or drugs. Having known both types of users, I see the program's core unchanged. Alcohol is a drug, and I’ve yet to meet an alcoholic who can casually use drugs, or vice versa. The emotions and recovery methods overlap, whether it's Al-Anon or Nar-Anon."

—Debbi

Inclusivity Without Other Affiliations

"As a grateful Al-Anon member, I believe this tradition welcomes anyone affected by a loved one's alcoholism. I disagree with excluding substance abusers; often, their struggles stem from trauma related to alcoholism. Many members are 'double winners,' facing both issues, which enriches our fellowship.

The phrase 'provided they have no other affiliation' suggests keeping meetings simple and focused, avoiding groups that require prior membership elsewhere, like 'women in recovery' or 'Christians in recovery.' This is my interpretation."

—Lin

Letting a Higher Power Judge

"During my first A.A. experience, I was solely an alcoholic, but many attendees struggled with drugs too. I learned that we should support all who seek help. On my second journey, I was both an alcoholic and drug user, and thankfully, I was welcomed. Working the 12 steps works regardless of the substance.

I’ve never met a drug user without a drinking problem. I would never turn anyone away; they are part of the same struggle. People who don’t belong naturally drift away. A.A. has equipped me to help anyone, not just those with addiction. We have closed meetings to protect anonymity, and judgment is best left to a higher power."

—Unknown

Read more:

• Conditions A-Z
• Addiction
• Alcohol Addiction
• Coping and Recovery

By Buddy T
Buddy T is an experienced writer and founding member of the Online Al-Anon Outreach Committee, dedicated to sharing insights on alcoholism. To honor the group's anonymity principles, he uses a pseudonym and does not share his photo on this platform.

See Our Editorial Process | Meet Our Review Board | Share Feedback

Was this page helpful? Thanks for your feedback!

Explore useful articles in Addiction as of 09-12-2023. The article titled " Understanding Tradition 3 in A.A.: Membership and Belonging " offers in-depth analysis and practical advice in the Addiction field. Each article is carefully crafted by experts to provide maximum value to readers.

The " Understanding Tradition 3 in A.A.: Membership and Belonging " article expands your knowledge in Addiction, keeps you informed about the latest developments, and helps you make well-informed decisions. Each article is based on unique content, ensuring originality and quality.