Metacritic Names 10 Worst TV Shows of 2025, Monster in Top 3
Metacritic highlights the year’s worst TV shows, led by a controversial Hulu legal drama and a new Monster installment that drew sharp critical backlash.
Metacritic has published its annual ranking of the worst TV shows of 2025. The list includes projects that received at least four professional reviews and is scored on a 0–100 Metascore. The site notes that fewer specialized outlets limited the pool, but the top picks reflect the year’s most talked-about misfires.
Top pick: All's Fair on Hulu leads the list with a 17/100 Metascore. The courtroom drama follows three affluent divorce lawyers, featuring Naomi Watts, Nisi Nash, and Kim Kardashian. Critics have been harsh, calling it ridiculous and truly terrible. Yet the show drew crowds online and was renewed for a second season.
Second place: Monster: The Ed Gein Story, another Ryan Murphy project, scores 28/100. Critics panned the series for tastelessness, overacting, and little meaningful storytelling.
Third: The Hunting Party from NBC, with a 34/100 score, follows a team chasing escaped criminals. Many critics saw it as a bland blend of familiar formats like Criminal Minds and The Blacklist, though NBC renewed it for a second season.
Rounding out the list are reality and lifestyle shows such as Simon Cowell: The Next Act, The Baldwins, With Love, Meghan, The Abandons, Celebrity Bear Hunt with Bear Grylls, The Z-Suite, and Countdown. Critics labeled these titles as out of touch or overlong, contributing to a year with several notable misfires.
Previously, Metacritic also highlighted the year’s 15 worst films, including The Electric State with Chris Pratt.
Full list of the 10 worst shows of 2025
- All's Fair (All's Fair, 2025)
- Monster: The Ed Gein Story (Monster: The Ed Gein Story, 2025)
- The Hunting Party (The Hunting Party, 2025)
- Simon Cowell: The Next Act (Simon Cowell: The Next Act, 2025)
- The Baldwins (The Baldwins, 2025)
- With Love, Meghan (With Love, Meghan, 2025)
- The Abandons (The Abandons, 2025)
- Celebrity Bear Hunt with Bear Grylls (Celebrity Bear Hunt with Bear Grylls, 2025)
- The Z-Suite (The Z-Suite, 2025)
- Countdown (Countdown, 2025)
Expert comment: A media analyst notes that critics and audiences alike are more discerning than ever. Expensive productions cannot compensate for weak writing or pacing.
Summary: The year 2025 brought several high-profile flops that sparked discussion about what makes a TV series work. Some titles drew large audiences despite negative reviews, while others failed to connect with critics. This list helps viewers separate flashy concepts from solid storytelling.
Key insight: A strong concept, tight writing, and smart pacing matter as much as a big budget in delivering a successful series.
Explore useful articles in Inspiring Movies & TV Shows as of 19-12-2025. The article titled " Metacritic Names 10 Worst TV Shows of 2025, Monster in Top 3 " offers in-depth analysis and practical advice in the Inspiring Movies & TV Shows field. Each article is carefully crafted by experts to provide maximum value to readers.
The " Metacritic Names 10 Worst TV Shows of 2025, Monster in Top 3 " article expands your knowledge in Inspiring Movies & TV Shows, keeps you informed about the latest developments, and helps you make well-informed decisions. Each article is based on unique content, ensuring originality and quality.