S&P 500 Hits Record High in 2023 as Consumer Discretionary Stocks Surge

In 2023, U.S. equity markets rebounded impressively, with the S&P 500 achieving a record closing high, propelled by a robust surge in consumer discretionary stocks. Early losses were overcome as energy shares climbed, fueled by positive vaccine developments and ongoing OPEC discussions on production cuts.

This article is part of our exclusive Market Insights series. Subscribe now to receive daily updates directly in your inbox.

Investors have intensified their focus on consumer discretionary sectors, signaling confidence in economic recovery and increased spending. Professional fund managers, initially slow to pivot, are now striving to catch up, especially following November's notable market gains exceeding 10%.

Historical data from LPL Financial indicates that a monthly gain of 10% or more is typically followed by further gains over the subsequent month more than half the time, and about 75% of the time over the next three months. December traditionally ranks as the second-best month for market performance, following November, with exceptions like the 10.8% drop in December 2018 illustrating market volatility.

Consumer Wants vs. Needs: Market Implications

The shift toward consumer discretionary stocks reflects growing optimism about post-pandemic spending, especially as vaccines become widely available. This sector includes industries such as automotive, home goods, luxury retail, and travel. Conversely, consumer staples—covering essentials like food, beverages, and household products—held steady during the pandemic, but the momentum is clearly moving toward discretionary spending.

As highlighted by JC Parets of AllStarCharts.com, the ratio between consumer discretionary (XLY ETF) and consumer staples (XLP ETF) has reached unprecedented levels, signaling a strong investor preference for recovery-oriented sectors. Interestingly, this ratio tends to reverse during market downturns, making consumer discretionary stocks a valuable economic indicator. Given that consumer spending accounts for approximately 70% of GDP, this trend is crucial for assessing economic health.

Mutual Funds Lag Behind in Recovery Rally

October's outflows from mutual funds and ETFs proved ill-timed, preceding November's market rebound. According to Bank of America's research, many mutual fund managers failed to re-enter the market promptly, with only one-third of large-cap active funds outperforming their Russell 1000 benchmarks in November. Year-to-date, just 36% of funds have surpassed their benchmarks, down from 40% in October.

Missed Opportunities in Energy and Financial Sectors

About 50% of large-cap funds were underweight in energy stocks, and 20% underweight in financials—two of the best-performing sectors with gains of +27% and +17% respectively. While caution around these volatile sectors is understandable, rapid sentiment shifts can lead to swift recoveries, challenging funds structured for slower pivots and contributing to October's outflows.

American Sentiment on Economy Turns Cautious

Nearly a year into the pandemic, many Americans express growing concern about the economy's trajectory. Despite expectations for a stronger recovery by this point, setbacks in controlling the virus have tempered optimism.

Recent Gallup polls reveal an uptick in the percentage of Americans who believe the economy is worsening, with only 40% perceiving improvement—a slight decline from the previous month, though still above April’s lows.

Have a news tip for our analysts? Contact us at tips@investopedia.com.

Explore useful articles in Markets News as of 08-12-2020. The article titled " S&P 500 Hits Record High in 2023 as Consumer Discretionary Stocks Surge " offers in-depth analysis and practical advice in the Markets News field. Each article is carefully crafted by experts to provide maximum value to readers.

The " S&P 500 Hits Record High in 2023 as Consumer Discretionary Stocks Surge " article expands your knowledge in Markets News, keeps you informed about the latest developments, and helps you make well-informed decisions. Each article is based on unique content, ensuring originality and quality.